Skip to Main content
Join our Loyalty Rewards Program Today!
  • Peter Pan Diner

Currently not accepting online orders

Peter Pan Diner

999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, NY
BREAKFAST
BURGERS / HOT DOGS
BETWEEN THE BREAD
WRAPS / PANINIS / QUESADILLAS
SALADS / SOUPS
APPETIZERS / SIDES
BEVERAGES/DESSERT

BREAKFAST

Sandwiches & Wraps

  • One Egg On A Kaiser Roll

    One Egg on a Kaiser Roll
    $6.15
  • One Egg & Cheese Sandwich

    One Egg and Cheese on a Kaiser Roll
    $7.20
  • Breakfast Wrap up to 3 Items

    Your choice of three ingredients with three scrambled eggs. Served with your choice of side.
    $18.85

Omelets

  • Greek Omelet

    Herbs, Feta Cheese, Onions and Spinach. Served with toast and your choice of side.
    $18.55
  • Western Omelet

    Ham, Peppers and Onions. Served with toast and your choice of side.
    $18.55
  • Farmer's Omelet

    Bacon, Ham, Mushrooms and Sausage. Served with toast and your choice of side.
    $18.55
  • Veggie Omelet

    Spinach, Mushrooms, Onions, Broccoli, Roasted Roma Tomatoes. Served with toast and your choice of side.
    $18.55
  • Avocado Omelet

    Bacon, Roasted Roma Tomatos and Pepper Jack. Served with toast and your choice of side.
    $18.55
  • Turkey Avocado Fusion Omelet

    Turkey, Avocado, Roasted Roma Tomatoes,Spinach and Swiss Cheese. Served with toast and your choice of side.
    $18.55
  • Mexican Omelet

    Chili, Cheddar Cheese and Sour Cream. Served with salsa, toast and your choice of side.
    $18.55

Pancakes

  • Classic Pan Stack Pancakes

    $13.40
  • Short Stack Pancakes

    $10.30
  • The Big Stack Show Pancakes

    Fresh Strawberries, Bluebarries and Banana
    $17.50
  • Chocolate Chip Pancakes

    $17.50
  • Blueberry And Almond Pancakes

    $17.50
  • Banana Walnut And Caramel Sauce Pancakes

    $17.50
  • Baked Apple And Cinnamon Swirl Pancakes

    $17.50
  • Oreo And Nutella Pancakes

    $17.50
  • Peanut Butter Pancakes

    $17.50

French Toast & Waffles

  • French Toast Bites

    Topped with Strawberries, Bluberries, Banana and Nutella,
    $16.95
  • Peter Pan Original French Toast

    Made with Challah Bread
    $15.95
  • French Toast With Fruit

    Challah Bread french toast topped with Strawberries, Blueberries and Banana
    $17.00
  • Belgian Waffle

    A golden, crisp on the outside, light-and-fluffy on the inside Belgian Waffle, made fresh to order
    $13.40
  • Belgian Waffle Topped With Fresh Fruit

    A golden, crisp on the outside, light-and-fluffy on the inside Belgian waffle, made fresh to order. Topped with Strawberries, Blueberries and Banana
    $17.50
  • Chicken & Waffles

    Golden, crispy Fried Chicken tenders served over a warm, fluffy Belgian Waffle.
    $21.10

BURGERS / HOT DOGS

Burgers

  • Jumbo Burger [No Fries]

    8oz Beef Burger on a Toasted Brioche Bun. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $12.90
  • Jumbo Burger Deluxe

    8oz Beef Burger on a Toasted Brioche Bun, served with Fries Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $18.05
  • Loaded Double Smash Burger

    Two Smashed Patties, layered with Melted Cheese, Bacon, Shoestring Onions, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato and House Sauce, served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries.
    $20.60
  • Patty Melt

    8 oz. Beef Burger smothered with Sautéed Onions, American Cheese and House Sauce on Grilled Rye Bread. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $20.60
  • Peter Pan's Classic Sliders

    Four classic sliders with sauteed Onions and American Cheese.
    $20.60
  • PPD House Burger

    8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Blue Cheese, Shoestring Onions and House Sauce on a toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $20.60
  • Cali Burger

    8oz Beef Burger topped with Smashed Avocado, Bacon and Melted Swiss Cheese served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $20.60
  • Call My Doctor Burger

    8 oz Beef Burger smothered with Blue Cheese, Sauteed Onions and Bacon on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $20.60
  • Pizza Burger

    8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Marinara Sauce and Melted Mozzarella Cheese, served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $18.95
  • The Unique Greek Burger

    8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Feta Cheese, Kalamata Olives, Tomato, spiced with Greek Oregano and Tzatziki Sauce on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $20.60
  • Cubano Burger

    8oz Beef Burger with Jack Daniels Pulled Pork, Diced Pineapple and Swiss Cheese served on a Toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed.
    $20.60
  • Mexi Max Burger

    8 oz. Beef Burger topped with Pepper Jack Cheese, Guacamole, Bacon and Tomatoes on a toasted Brioche Bun with Fries. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $20.60
  • Lone Star Chili Cheeseburger

    8 oz Beef Burger loaded with Beef Chili and Cheddar Cheese on a Brioche Bun with Fries. 8oz Beef Burger on a Toasted Brioche Bun. Alternate burger options: 6oz. Turkey, Veggie, Black Bean Chipotle and Double Smashed
    $20.60

Hot Dog Heaven

  • Classic Hot Dogs

    Two classic Hot Dogs with your choice of toppings served with Fries.
    $10.30
  • Chili Cheese Dog

    Two Hot Dogs topped with Chili and Melted Chedder Cheese.
    $11.35

BETWEEN THE BREAD

Sandwiches

  • BLT

    Bacon, Lettuce and Tomato on your choice of Bread served with Fries or Soup
    $13.40
  • Classic Reuben

    Corned Beef or Pastrami with Sauerkraut, melted Swiss, Thousand Island Dressing on grilled Rye Bread. Served with Potato Salad Served with Fries or Soup
    $20.60
  • Grilled Cheese

    Classic Grilled Cheese with your choice of bread and cheese, grilled to golden perfection served with Fries or Soup
    $12.35
  • Pear & Fig Formaggio Melt

    Creamy Gruyère Cheese, sweet sliced Pear, and rich Fig Jam layered between your choice of bread and grilled until golden brown with a perfectly crisp, buttery finish Served with Fries or Soup
    $16.50
  • Tuna Melt

    House-made Tuna Salad served with melted American Cheese on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
    $15.45
  • Tuna Salad Sandwich

    House-made Tuna Salad on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
    $14.45
  • Chicken Salad Sandwich

    House-made Chicken Salad on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
    $14.45
  • Turkey Club Sandwich

    Turkey, Lettuce, Tomato, Bacon on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Grilled Chicken Club Sandwich

    Grilled Chicken, Tomato, Lettuce and Bacon on your choice of bread served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Fried Crispy Chicken Sandwich

    Golden, crispy fried chicken breast topped with our signature sauce and served on a buttery Toasted Brioche Bun. Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Texas Smoke Sandwich

    Fried Chicken, melted Chedder Cheese, Bacon, BBQ Sauce on a toasted Sourdough Bread served with Fries or Soup
    $20.60
  • Philly Cheesesteak

    Oven roasted Prime Rib, Onions and Peppers topped with Cheese Sauce Served with Fries or Soup
    $26.75
  • Steakhouse Sandwich

    Sliced Skirt Steak, grilled Onions and Peppers topped with Melted Provolone and Chimichurri Sauce on Garlic Bread Served with Fries or Soup
    $25.75
  • New Champ

    Sliced oven roasted Prime Rib with Chedder Cheese and Mushrooms on a Toasted Hero Served with Fries or Soup
    $25.75
  • Roast Beef Sandwich

    Roast Beef with Lettuce and Tomato Served with Fries or Soup
    $16.50
  • Hot Open Roast Beef

    Served with Fries or Soup
    $22.65
  • Hot Open Turkey

    Served with Fries or Soup
    $22.65
  • Long Islander Sandwich

    Fried Filet, Shredded Lettuce, Tomato, and Tarter Sauce on a Brioche Bun, served with Fries or Soup
    $22.65
  • Chili Melt Sandwich

    Chili, Chedder Cheese, Jalapenos on your choice of Bread served with Fries or Soup
    $14.45
  • Carving Board Sandwich

    Create your own sandwich served with Fries or Soup
    $15.50

Souvlaki/Gyro

  • Souvlaki

    Served with Greek Salad and your choice of Rice, Fries or Soup
    $25.75
  • Chicken Souvlaki

    Served with Greek Salad and your choice of Rice, Fries or Soup
    $25.75
  • Gyro

    Served with a Greek Salad and Rice, Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Chicken Gryo

    Chicken Gyro served with Greek Salad and Rice, Fries or Soup
    $19.60

WRAPS / PANINIS / QUESADILLAS

Wraps

  • Brooklyn Bridge Pastrami Wrap

    Hot NY Style Pastrami, Swiss Cheese and Sauerkraut served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Buffalo Chicken Wrap

    Fried Chicken Strips Topped with Frank's Hot Sauce, Jack Blend Cheese, Lettuce, Tomato Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Chicken, Avocado, BLT Wrap

    Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Mango Tango Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Lettuce, Mandarin Oranges, Pineapple, Red Pepper. Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Greek Salad Chicken Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Romaine Lettuce, Tomato, Cucumber, Red Onion, Kalamata Olives, Feta Cheese, Tzatziki and Greek Salad Dressing. Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap

    Grilled Chicken, Caesar Salad, Croutons. Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Taco Wrap

    Beef or Turkey, Cheddar Cheese, Lettuce, Sour Cream and Tomato with Salsa on the Side. Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Hot Honey Chicken Wrap

    Crispy Chicken, Cole Slaw, diced Bacon, Pickles and Hot Honey. Served with Fries or Soup
    $19.60
  • Steakhouse Wrap

    Grilled Skirt Steak, Sauteed Onions & Peppers, melted Jack Cheese and Chipotle Aioli. Served with Fries or Soup
    $21.80
  • Korean BBQ Steak Wrap

    Grilled Skirt Steak coated in a savory Korean BBQ Sauce, layered with Rice, Broccoli and Lettuce. Served with Fries or Soup
    $20.75
  • Tom Turkey Wrap

    Roasted Turkey, Lettuce and Tomato. Served with Fries or Soup
    $18.55
  • Gobble Gobble Wrap

    Roast Turkey and Stuffing with Cranberry Sauce and Gravy on the side. Served with Fries or Soup
    $18.00

Paninis

  • Ham And Cheddar Melt Panini

    Honey Maple Ham, Sharp Cheddar Cheese, Tomato, Pickle slices, Honey Dijon Mustard on Ciabatta Bread. Served with Fries or Soup
    $20.35
  • Peter Pan Panini

    Grilled Chicken, Mozzarella, Grilled Spinach and Roasted Red Peppers on Ciabatta Bread. Served with Fries or Soup
    $20.35
  • Steak And Blue Pressed Panini

    Sliced Skirt Steak, Crispy Onions and Blue Cheese on Ciabatta Bread. Served with Fries or Soup
    $23.65
  • Turkey Club Panini

    Roasted Turkey, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers and Tomato on Ciabatta Bread. Served with Fries or Soup
    $20.35
  • Veggie Panini

    Mushrooms, Mozzarella Cheese, Onion, Black Olives, Roasted Red Peppers and a Balsamic Glaze on Ciabatta Bread. Served with Fries or Soup
    $20.35
  • Chicken Cutlet Parmigiana Panini

    Crispy breaded Chicken Cutlet, Tomato Sauce and Mozzarella on Ciabatta Bread. Served with Fries or Soup.
    $20.35

Quesadillas

  • Chicken Quesadilla

    Grilled Chicken, Onions, Peppers and Jack Blend Cheese.
    $22.65
  • Garden Of Eatin' Quesadilla

    Grilled fresh Spinach, Garlic, Tomatoes, Onions and Black Beans sautéed in Olive Oil with your choice of Cheese, Salsa and Sour Cream
    $22.65
  • Pork And Cheese Overload Quesadilla

    Creamy Mac & Cheese and Pulled Pork
    $22.65
  • Roman Holiday Quesadilla

    Grilled Shrimp, Garlic, Mozzarella Cheese, Olive Oil, Onions and Tomatoes
    $25.70
  • South Of The Border Quesadilla

    Chili, Beans, Fresh Spinach, Three Cheeses, Salsa and Sour Cream
    $20.60
  • Steak Quesadilla

    Skirt Steak, Jack Cheese, Mushrooms and Onions
    $25.70

SALADS / SOUPS

Salads

  • Caesar Salad

    Chrisp Romaine Lettuce, Parmesan, Garlic Croutons and creamy Caesar Dressing
    $18.55
  • Our Famous Greek Salad

    Greek Salad topped with Feta Cheese and Kalamata Olives and Chickpeas
    $20.10
  • Chef's Salad

    Assorted Greens with Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Swiss Cheese and a hard boiled Egg
    $25.25
  • Cobb Salad

    Diced Chicken or Turkey, Bacon, Avocado, Bleu Cheese, hard boiled Egg and Tomato with Red Wine Vinaigrette
    $23.20
  • Fruiti-Aki Salad

    Teriyaki Chicken, Mandarin Oranges, Strawberries, Banana, Grape Tomatoes, Pineapple and sliced Almonds served over Mixed Greens
    $24.00
  • Taco Salad

    Seasoned Beef or Turkey, shredded Lettuce, diced Tomatoes, Jack Cheese, Guacamole, Sour Cream and Salsa
    $24.00
  • Crispy Chicken Salad

    Fried Chicken Cutlet strips, Romaine Lettuce, Bacon, Cheddar Cheese, Black Olives and Cherry Tomatoes
    $24.00
  • Santa Fe Cajun Chicken Salad

    Grilled Cajun Chicken over crisp Romaine Lettuce, Monterey Jack Cheese, Guacamole, Sour Cream, Salsa and topped with Garlic Croutons
    $24.00
  • Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad

    Grilled Chicken over Caesar Salad, and topped with Garlic Croutons
    $24.00
  • Grilled Salmon Caesar Salad

    Grilled Salmon over Caesar Salad and topped with Garlic Croutons
    $25.35
  • Spinach Salad

    Fresh Spinach, Mushrooms, Bacon, Boiled Egg and Red Onion
    $20.60
  • Tossed Salad

    Classic Tossed Salad with Tomatoes, Cucumbers, Olives and Onions
    $18.55

Soups

  • Soup (Pint)

    Chicken Noodle, Greek Lemon Orzo or Matzah Ball
    $6.20
  • Soup (Quart)

    Chicken Noodle, Greek Lemon Orzo or Matzah Ball
    $10.30

Chili

Hearty chili topped with melted cheddar cheese
  • Chili with Cheese

    Hearty chili topped with melted cheddar cheese
    $6.99

APPETIZERS / SIDES

Appetizers

  • Loaded Nachos

    Tortillas chips topped with Black Beans, Olives, Salsa, Guacamole, diced Tomatoes, Sour Cream, warm Queso Sauce, Scallions. and topped with Chili
    $21.65
  • Loaded Tater Tots

    Tater Tots topped with Cheese Sauce, Bacon, and Scallions.
    $12.35
  • Disco Fries

    Melted Mozzarella and Gravy over French Fries.
    $15.45
  • Chili Cheese Fries

    Crispy golden fries topped with hearty chili and melted chedder cheese
    $15.45
  • Chicken Wings

    12 wings served Naked or with Hot Honey, General Tso’s, or Frank's RedHot Sauce
    $19.60
  • Fried Calamari

    Tender calamari, lightly breaded and fried to a golden crisp, served hot with marinara sauce and fresh lemon
    $19.60
  • Everything Bavarian Pretzel Sticks

    Four fresh baked soft bavarian pretzel sticks served with your choice of dipping sauce
    $14.45
  • Mozzarella Squares

    Four crispy, golden-breaded mozzarella squares filled with warm, melted mozzarella cheese
    $16.50
  • Jalapeno Poppers

    Crispy breaded jalapeños filled with creamy cheese and fried until golden
    $14.45
  • Fried Pickles

    Fried Pickles served with your choice of dipping sauce
    $14.45
  • Spanakopita

    Flaky phyllo pastry filled with a savory blend of spinach, feta cheese, onions, and herbs, baked until golden and crisp
    $13.40
  • Baked Clams

    Tender chopped clams blended with seasoned breadcrumbs, garlic, herbs, and a touch of lemon, then baked until golden brown
    $19.60
  • Cheeseburger Sliders

    Three juicy mini beef burgers served on toasted slider buns
    $14.45
  • Pulled Pork Sliders

    Three tender pulled pork tossed in barbecue sauce, served on toasted slider buns
    $14.45
  • Chicken Tenders

    Crispy, golden brown chicken tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce
    $17.25
  • Chicken Tenders with French Fries

    Crispy, golden brown chicken tenders served with your choice of dipping sauce. Served with Fries
    $21.40
  • Mediterranean Hummus & Pita

    Creamy hummus topped with Kalamata olives, diced tomatoes, and a drizzle of olive oil
    $13.40

Sides

  • French Fries

    $7.20
  • Steak Fries

    $8.25
  • Seasoned Waffle Fries

    $8.25
  • Seasoned Curly Fries

    $8.25
  • Sweet Potato Fries

    $8.25
  • Tater Tots

    $8.25
  • Home Fries

    $8.15
  • Onion Rings

    $9.30
  • Bacon/Ham/Sausage

    Choice of Bacon, Ham or Sausage
    $5.80
  • Turkey Bacon Or Turkey Sausage

    $7.20
  • Canadian Bacon

    $7.55
  • Corned Beef Hash

    $7.85
  • Lox

    $14.95
  • Gyro Meat

    $10.30
  • Sliced Turkey or Roast Beef

    $5.95
  • Grilled Chicken

    $8.25
  • Fresh Fruit Salad

    Fresh Strawberries, Bluberries and Banana
    $4.75
  • Chickpea Salad

    $4.99
  • Potato Salad

    Creamy, house-made potato salad prepared with tender potatoes, a classic side
    $4.25
  • Cole Slaw

    $3.50
  • Cottage Cheese

    $4.95
  • Vegetable

    Your choice of Broccoli, Spinach or Mushrooms
    $4.50
  • Grape Leaves

    A serving of five Grape Leaves
    $4.45
  • Avocado

    $3.50
  • Feta Cheese

    $5.45
  • Greek Dinner Salad

    The perfect size to have with a meal
    $11.35
  • Tossed Salad

    Traditional tossed salad, the perfect size to have with a meal
    $9.30
  • Spaghetti With Tomato Sauce

    Tender spaghetti served with our classic tomato sauce
    $10.30
  • Bread Basket

    Choice of Artisan Rolls or Garlic Bread
    $4.65
  • Pita Bread

    $3.10

BEVERAGES/DESSERT

Chilled Drinks

  • Fountain Soda

    $3.75
  • Club Soda

    $2.75
  • Iced Tea (Sweet)

    $4.25
  • Brewed Iced Tea (Unsweetened)

    Freshly brewed in-house and served ice-cold
    $4.70
  • Iced Coffee

    $4.25
  • Cold Brew

    $5.99
  • Lemonade

    $4.25
  • Juice (Small)

    Orange, Apple, Cranberry, Grapefruit, Pineapple and V8
    $4.50
  • Juice (Large)

    Orange, Apple, Cranberry, Grapefruit, Pineapple and V8
    $5.50
  • Milk (Small)

    $3.50
  • Milk (Large)

    $4.25
  • Chocolate Milk (Small)

    $3.95
  • Chocolate Milk (Large)

    $4.95

Coffee/Tea

  • Coffee

    $3.99
  • Decaf Coffee

    $3.99
  • Hot Tea

    $3.99
  • Hot Chocolate

    $3.50

Desserts

  • Apple Pie

    $6.99
  • Assorted Layer Cakes

    $7.49
  • Creamy Cheesecake

    $8.49
  • Creamy Rice Pudding

    $6.49
  • Creamy Strawberry Cheesecake

    $9.49
  • Jumbo Cookie

    $4.49

Roast Beef Sandwich

$16.50

Roast Beef with Lettuce and Tomato Served with Fries or Soup

Customize your item

Add-On

Optional

French Fries or Soup Side

Required
Select 1

Bread Choice

Select up to 1
Request advisory
We'll do our best to accommodate special requests but may not be able to honor all substitutes. Extra charges may apply.
1

Peter Pan Diner Location and Hours

(631) 665-1788
999 Sunrise Highway, Bay Shore, NY 11706
Open now • Closes at 10PM
Facebook logoInstagram logo
Toast logopowered by toast
  • Terms of Service
  • |Privacy Statement